Carlsen-Niemann (chess) scandal: Carlsen encourages dishonest accusation in opposition to Niemann with out offering proof | Chess Information

Carlsen-Niemann (chess) scandal: Carlsen encourages dishonest accusation in opposition to Niemann with out offering proof | Chess Information

Magnus Carlsen remains to be stoning Hans Niemann, who defeated him two weeks in the past within the Sinquefield Cup in St. Louis (USA), and hiding his hand. He then withdrew from the match after the third spherical with out explaining the explanations. At the moment he gave up his sport in opposition to the American after making solely his first transfer within the sixth spherical of the Julius Baer quick on-line match. Whereas the networks are divided between those that lynch Niemann, 19, for dishonest and people who criticize the Norwegian for insinuating with out proof, the Worldwide Chess Federation (FIDE) assures EL PAÍS that neither of them has filed an official criticism.

The tone of the scandal continues to escalate to such an extent that even Carlsen’s compatriot and former assistant, grandmaster Jon Ludvig Hammer, reacted to the brand new scandal like this: “Dropping on goal is completely unacceptable behaviour. It’s the most unsportsmanlike factor you are able to do in a contest,” he stated throughout the dwell broadcast on Norwegian tv. The British Jovanka Houska, one of many dwell commentators on the Chess24 platform, of which Carlsen was the biggest shareholder till a month in the past, when it was purchased by, stated in the identical vein: “You’ll be able to’t do that. And he should do greater than clarify. You’ll be able to’t simply say, ‘Yeah, I feel you cheated,’ and begin a witch hunt. What he has to say is: ‘That is my proof.’”

Actually, the Julius Baer match, which is a part of the Champions Chess Tour circuit, is organized by the Play Magnus group, of which Chess24 is a component. The director of that collection of competitions, Arne Horvei, defined that Niemann has been invited “in accordance with the principles of the circuit, as a result of he completed within the prime eight of the earlier match.” And he added: “Now we have rigorously analyzed many video games on the circuit, and there’s no indication that his video games contain any form of dishonest.”

The issue that almost all fuels the defenders of Carlsen’s angle is that Niemann admitted, in an interview with Chess24, that he cheated in on-line video games when he was between 12 and 16 years previous, though he certified that he had realized from his errors as an adolescent and who has “by no means” cheated in face-to-face video games. Virtually all of the elite grandmasters who’ve spoken out, together with former world champion Gari Kasparov, consider that Niemann didn’t cheat within the Sinquefield Cup and ask Carlsen, who has supplied no proof, for a proof. When he introduced his withdrawal from that match in a tweet, the Norwegian quoted a phrase from soccer coach José Mourinho: “If I communicate, I’ll have severe issues.” Since then he has not given interviews; and his father, Henrik, confirmed yesterday that he won’t give any throughout Julius Baer both.

After eight days out of the scheduled fifteen, Carlsen shares 2nd place with 17-year-old Indian prodigy Rameshbabu Praggnanandhaa; the chief is one other Indian prodigy, Arjun Erigaisi, 19. After the absurdity of his sport with Niemann (1 d4 Nf6 2 c4 and Carlsen resigned), the champion drew a fast-paced struggle with Praggnanandhaa and brilliantly gained the American Levón Aronian. This, of Armenian origin, known as the Scandinavian “paranoid” after his withdrawal from the Sinquefield Cup. However now he clarifies: “I perceive Magnus’s frustration as a result of I do know issues that I did not know that day. As an instance I am within the center proper now. I’m clear that Hans’ habits in on-line tournaments has not been the cleanest”. One other of the Play Magnus commentators, the American Alejandro Ramírez, born in Costa Rica, identified: “What occurred at this time confirms that Magnus is satisfied that Hans has executed one thing mistaken. I do not know what it’s precisely, however I do know that it have to be one thing so robust that Magnus has to return out and say one thing.”

Subscribe to weekly bulletin ‘Fantastic transfer’, by Leontxo Garcia

Subscribe to proceed studying

learn with out limits

#CarlsenNiemann #chess #scandal #Carlsen #encourages #dishonest #accusation #Niemann #offering #proof #Chess #Information

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button